fbpx
The Great Revolt: Inside the Populist Coalition Reshaping American Politics
Salena Zito
A CNN political analyst and a Republican strategist reframe the… Read more
The Case for Nationalism: How It Made Us Powerful, United, and Free
Rich Lowry
It is one of our most honored clichés that America… Read more
Bad News: How Woke Media Is Undermining Democracy
Batya Ungar-Sargon
Something is wrong with American journalism. Long before “fake news”… Read more
The Quartet: Orchestrating the Second American Revolution, 1783-1789
Joseph Ellis
In The Quartet, Pulitzer Prize–winning historian Joseph Ellis tells the unexpected… Read more
Ani Maamin: Biblical Criticism, Historical Truth, and the Thirteen Principles of Faith
Joshua Berman
For two centuries the academic study of the Bible has… Read more

More Books »

What’s Wrong with Rights? (2020)

Nigel Biggar

Are natural rights ‘nonsense on stilts’, as Jeremy Bentham memorably put it? Must the very notion of a right be individualistic, subverting the common good? Should the right against torture be absolute, even though the heavens fall? Are human rights universal or merely expressions of Western
neo-imperial arrogance? Are rights ethically fundamental, proudly impervious to changing circumstances? Should judges strive to extend the reach of rights from civil Hamburg to anarchical Basra? Should judicial oligarchies, rather than legislatures, decide controversial ethical issues by inventing
novel rights? Ought human rights advocates learn greater sympathy for the dilemmas facing those burdened with government?

These are the questions that What’s Wrong with Rights? addresses. In doing so, it draws upon resources in intellectual history, legal philosophy, moral philosophy, moral theology, human rights literature, and the judgments of courts. It ranges from debates about property in medieval
Christendom, through Confucian rights-scepticism, to contemporary discussions about the remedy for global hunger and the justification of killing. And it straddles assisted dying in Canada, the military occupation of Iraq, and genocide in Rwanda.

What’s Wrong with Rights? concludes that much contemporary rights-talk obscures the importance of fostering civic virtue, corrodes military effectiveness, subverts the democratic legitimacy of law, proliferates publicly onerous rights, and undermines their authority and credibility. The
solution to these problems lies in the abandonment of rights-fundamentalism and the recovery of a richer public discourse about ethics, one that includes talk about the duty and virtue of rights-holders.

Purchase the Book